Count the vote · October 18
Your vote deserves better than this.
About 2,300 mail ballots sat in a Canada Post warehouse for days because City Hall had not filed a form. On election day the internet went down at voting places, and the City put James Bay voters on a bus downtown. Fifteen votes decided the last council seat. We are asking the City for a full accounting and for a review from outside City Hall. Sign up and we will tell you what the City answers, and what you can do about it.
What happened, with sources Tell us what you saw Count me in
Victoria election
The fight to make your vote count.
Who we voted for: council
- Marg Gardiner Elected
- Stephen Hammond Elected
- Arthur McInnis
- Karen Rothe
- Wendy Bowkett Elected
- Melissa Cseszko Elected
And for mayor
The six were endorsed by Victoria's firefighters too. Why these seven
Know someone who usually skips city elections? Send them a text.
The Gang of 5 council and Mayor Alto pushed through far-reaching and consequential development rules most residents never heard about, and raised your city taxes 35% while in office. On October 17 Victoria answered. Now the question is how the vote itself was run.
Stay in the know
The election is over and city hall gets back to work. Get our short emails on what council decides and what it costs, and stay connected with neighbours who care about Victoria.
Three things you can do today
The official results are due by 4 p.m. on Wednesday, October 21. Before then, the City should publish the mail ballot numbers and promise to keep every record.
Email the City
One message to the chief election officer, copied to the mayor and council. The words are filled in; add your address and anything that happened to you.
Text a friend
Most people have not heard what happened. One text from you does more than anything we can post.
Tell us what happened to you
A mail ballot that came late or never, a line you had to leave, campaigning at a voting place: we are collecting accounts for the lawyers.
- Advance votingOct 7, 13, 14 and 15 · confirmed by the City
- Election dayVoting places open 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
- Voting by mailRequest your ballot by Oct 9, 4 p.m.
Stay connected after the election
We'll keep watching council and writing up what it decides in plain language. Join our email list to stay in the know, or follow us on Facebook and Instagram.
We are your neighbours
We are a grass-roots, community-based network committed to change at Victoria City Hall. We are issues driven, and we are not endorsed by, supported by, or affiliated with any political organization or special interest group.
Victoria deserves better than this
Over the past four years, a majority on Council, the five councillors residents call the Gang of 5, has eroded public trust and changed Victoria for the worse by undermining the safeguards of local democracy: consultation, transparency and accountability. What did we get instead? Little citizen input, quick decisions, narrow in scope and rationale, and favouritism to special interests.
Victoria deserves better. Your voice should count between elections, not just on one day in October.
October 17 was when you got a say. The follow-through is now.
Good government is something we do together. On October 17 Victoria voted; between elections, the work is holding council to what it promised.
Explore other community organizations
Neighbourhood groups across Victoria organized around local issues and the 2026 municipal election, and they are staying organized.
- Our Fernwood, Our VictoriaFernwood neighbourhood civic networkourfernwoodourvictoria.ca
- Our Rockland, Our VictoriaRockland neighbourhood civil society networkourrocklandourvictoria.ca
- Our Vic West, Our VictoriaVic West neighbourhood grassroots networkourvicwestourvictoria.ca
- Our Oaklands, Our VictoriaOaklands civil society networkouroaklandsourvictoria.ca
- Our James Bay, Our VictoriaJames Bay neighbourhood citizen groupourjamesbayourvictoria.ca
- Our Fairfield Gonzales, Our VictoriaFairfield and Gonzales neighbourhood citizen groupourfairfieldgonzalesourvictoria.ca
Safe VictoriaVictoria's firefighters, IAFF Local 730, and their public safety endorsementssafevictoria.ca
Community Voices MatterShort, factual surveys on city council decisions, backed by the voting recordcommunityvoicesmatter.ca
Six key areas need urgent fixing
The Gang of 5 council and mayor failed to listen to their citizens and left behind a devastating record that threatens the future of Victoria. See what they did and how to fix the damage.
-
Governance and public trust
From a council that does what it wants, to one that answers for what it decides.
-
Development and neighbourhoods
From a one-size-fits-all plan for development, to planning that values the uniqueness of your neighbourhood.
-
Housing and affordability
From bulldoze and build anything, to affordable homes people can actually rent and buy.
-
The urban forest
From planting saplings as replacements, to keeping the mature trees already standing.
-
Transportation and infrastructure
From growth first and pipes later, to infrastructure funded before approval.
-
Safety and well-being
From money spent, to results for residents, measured and reported.
The record, 2022 to 2026
What the Gang of 5 council did with four years
We are a network of citizens fed up with a majority of council forcing their vision on the city. Specifically, "the Gang of 5" (Councillors Dell, Caradonna, Loughton, Kim and Thompson), together with Mayor Alto, have undertaken the following. Judge for yourself.
-
A Parks Sequencing Plan with limited consultation
The plan approved the re-design of Centennial Square and pushed the mega Crystal Pool project forward, with limited consultation with the citizens who pay for both.
-
$15 million of land bought without asking
The city purchased Romeo's on Blanshard for $11 million, to eventually become a park, and Hermann's for roughly $4 million, again without consulting citizens. Parks, yes. But who would agree that a park right beside Blanshard is a good idea?
-
Taxes up every single year, and a raise they backed down on
The residential increase has climbed every budget of this term: 6.0, then 7.93, then 8.18, now 9.34 percent, roughly 35 percent compounded, while the announced headlines stayed conveniently smaller. In March 2024 council also voted itself a 25 percent raise, from $52,420 to $65,525, effective that May rather than at the next election. It backed down after public objection, and the smaller rise that survived does not start until after October 17.
-
Downtown left to fend for itself until election year
Council all but abandoned downtown business owners to crime and disorder for most of their mandate, and acted only in their last year, before the election, with the Community, Safety and Wellbeing Plan.
-
"Social Service Centres" allowed anywhere, without notice
Council approved a policy that allows social service centres, including homeless shelters, to open anywhere in Victoria without the community, or even council, being aware it is occurring.
-
Bike lanes built without meaningful consultation
The continual construction of bike lanes has gone ahead corridor after corridor without meaningful consultation with the businesses, residents and road users affected by them, including cyclists themselves.
-
The worst of all: an OCP almost nobody knew about
Council approved an Official Community Plan that less than 2 percent of the populace is even aware of. At no time was the public consulted when council asked staff to create a plan that would allow 4-storey condos on every lot in Victoria.
-
A governance review, ignored
Clearly this council learned nothing from the MNP governance review prepared for the last council, which found that people want to be consulted and listened to, not consulted and ignored.
That is the record of five councillors and the mayor. Change meant none of them going back, and none of the people they backed getting in. We named six who should; four of them were elected, and three of the five went back.
One plan now decides what can be built on your street.
The biggest change to city planning in a generation passed with fewer than 2,500 survey responses. We read the plan so you do not have to, and wrote down what matters.
- 4 storeysminimum building height now allowed on residential lots citywide
- 1.5 metreshow close a new building can sit to your property line
Answers before you ask
Who is behind the Sustainable Victoria Network?
Volunteer residents from neighbourhoods across Victoria who watch council meetings, read the agendas, and publish what they find in plain language. The network is independent, with no party and no affiliation with the City of Victoria. The members who agreed to be named are on the About page.
Who are the "Gang of 5"?
The nickname residents use for the five councillors who vote as a bloc: Matt Dell, Jeremy Caradonna, Krista Loughton, Susan Kim and Dave Thompson, usually joined by Mayor Marianne Alto. The full story is in our glossary, the decisions are on this page above, and who backed whom in the 2026 election is on the candidate tracker. Change starts with not sending them back and not electing the people they were backing, and we named six people to vote for instead; four of them were elected.
Why does the city say 7.28% tax when my notice says 9.34%?
Because the announced number blends property classes. For 2026, council assigned homes a tax of 9.34% and business 4.78%, then announced the blended 7.28. The year-by-year numbers, the extra fees, and the sources are on the real tax bill page.
I rent. Does city hall really affect me?
More than almost anyone. The new Official Community Plan shapes whether your building gets redeveloped and what compensation you get when it happens. Most Victoria households rent, and every renter ballot counts the same as every homeowner ballot. What we want changed is on the housing and affordability page.
What is this Official Community Plan everyone mentions?
Victoria 2050, adopted October 2, 2025. It replaced every neighbourhood plan in the city and allows buildings of at least four storeys on residential lots citywide. Our plain-language walkthrough covers what it means for owners, renters, trees and heritage.
What will you send me if I sign up?
Short updates by email: what council decided, what it costs, and when you can have your say. Unsubscribe anytime with one click. We never sell or share your information, which is set out in our privacy note.
Where the deep detail lives
- Election 2026 gathers everything from the campaign: who ran, who we voted for and why, how the vote worked, and the debates.
- Count the vote sets out what went wrong on election day, with sources, and what we are asking the City for.
- The OCP guide walks through the 2025 Official Community Plan clause by clause.
- The real tax bill traces where the money went, with every figure sourced.
- The media tracker collects what Victorians have written about city hall, sorted by issue.
- The glossary explains the terms council uses in plain language.
Stay connected after the election.
Get our short emails and follow us on Facebook. Council keeps making decisions between elections, and we'll keep you posted.